Winks & Twinkles & Tenacious “P” - The Debate That Ain’t »
By Roberta Rosenberg on Oct 3, 2008 | In Occasional Rantings | 5 Comments
Popcorn and Sleepy Time tea at the ready, I thought I was going to be watching a debate. He talks, she responds, and the moderator breaks up the fist-fight ugliness.
Instead, I heard this (direct from the transcript):
… I may not answer the questions that either the moderator or you want to hear, but I’m going to talk straight to the American people …
Hmm. I got to wondering how a client might react when having handed over a set of guidelines for a new campaign heard “I don’t really care to follow the guidelines you’ve just given me. I’m just going to write it straight to your customers.”
I think we’d be quickly shown the door, if not forcibly removed due to fear we were completely wacky and might cause someone great harm.
I wonder why the moderator didn’t step in with a “Governor Palin, this is a debate between you and Senator Biden. Not a stump speech. Please respond to the Senator and step lively. We only have XX minutes left in this segment.”
But that’s me. I like keeping people and projects focused and on track.
No wonder interviews give Palin the yips. She doesn’t like the format. I have to admit tho, it would be intriguing to watch her in a typical, free-for-all press conference — all perky poses and talking points that don’t quite connect to the questions being asked — but I’ll leave that to Tina Fey and the SNL comedy crew to sketch out that scenario.
I know, I know. Like you I was a little sad we didn’t get at least one “Sir, you are no Jack Kennedy!” moment or major foul-ups. (I did like her “O’Biden mash-up. That was fun.) But as political performances go, it was reasonably good theater.
Back to what ‘tackling the task’ means … if we treat last night’s debate as an actual debate, well, you just can’t give her a passing grade. Even the third grade kids in her shout out last night know what happens when you fail to follow the directions of an assignment.
You get an F no matter how gosh darn cute you are. Period.






